西部片Top10

摘录部分法国学者的“西部片Top10”,他们基本上是阅片无数的专家,但西部之大,历史之长,Top10这个项目始终众口难调,而且根本不可能,因此这个节目,仅供大家选片藏片娱乐。世上没有任何一部经典西部片是完美的,因为总有另外一部经典西部片拍到了他没拍到的东西。不过,法国人的口感委实刁钻,像Allan Dwan这样被好莱坞遗忘的人物,竟成为他们西部遗珠中的英雄,而John Sturges、Richard Brooks、Arthur Penn、Clint Eastwood等人悉数不放在眼里。借此机会,你也可以看看阅片无数的Magasa的西部片Top30。Western Top10,a misson impossible forever。

让·米特里(Jean Mitry),法国电影理论家(排名不分先后):

1. Stagecoach, John Ford
2. My Darling Clementine, John Ford
3. Yellow Sky, William Wellmann
4. Wagonmaster, John Ford
5. The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, John Huston
6. Seven men from now, Budd Boetticher
7. The Naked Spur, Anthony Mann
8. Rio Bravo, Howard Hawks
9. Johnny Guitar, Nicholas Ray
10. Ride the High Country, Sam Peckinpah


雷蒙·贝卢尔(Raymond Bellour),法国大学教授,西部片专家(排名分先后):

1. The Far Country, Anthony Mann
2. Rancho Notorious, Fritz Lang
3. The Naked Spur, Anthony Mann
4. Colorado Territory, Raoul Walsh
5. The Big Sky, Howard Hawks
6. Wagonmaster, John Ford
7. The Plainsman, De Mille
8. The Unforgiven, John Huston
9. Forty Guns, Samuel Fuller
10. Western Union, Fritz Lang

贝特朗·塔瓦尼埃(Bertrand Tavernier),法国著名导演,电影学者(排名分先后):

1. The Hanging Tree, Delmer Daves
2. 3h 10 to Yuma, Delmer Daves
3. Run of the arrow, Samuel Fuller
4. Red River, Howard Hawks
5. Silver Lode, Allan Dwan
6. The Searchers, John Ford
7. Comanche Station, Budd Boetticher
8. Johnny Guitar, Nicholas Ray
9. The Wonderful Country, Robert Parrish
10. Winchester 73, Anthony Mann

罗热·泰耶尔(Roger Tailleur),法国著名影评人,曾效力《正片》杂志,与特吕弗对峙多年,西部片专家,关于此人可参考我的专栏文章《罗热·泰耶尔的正片人生》(排名分先后);

1. My Darling Clementine, John Ford
1. Wagonmaster, John Ford
3. Rio Bravo, Howard Hawks
3. The Big Sky, Howard Hawks
5. The Last Frontier, Anthony Mann
5. The Hanging Tree, Dermer Daves
7. The Searchers, John Ford
8. Tennessee’s Partner, Allan Dwan
9. The Unforgiven, John Huston
10. River of no Return, Otto Preminger

让·瓦格纳(Jean Wagner),法国西部片学者(排名不分先后):

1. The Big Sky, Howard Hawks
2. The Last Hunt, Richard Brooks
3. The Naked Spur, Anthony Mann
4. River of no Rerurn, Otto Preminger
5. Taza, Son of Cochise, Douglas Sirk
6. Johnny Guitar, Nicholas Ray
7. Man without a star, King Vidor
8. Rancho Notorious, Fritz Lang
9. Silver Lode, Allan Dwan
10. Vera Cruz, Robert Aldrich

附赠,昆廷·塔伦蒂诺(Quentin Tarantino)西部片Top 3(排名分先后):

1. Ria Bravo, Howard Hawks
2. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, Sergio Leone
3. One-Eyed Jacks, Marlon Brando

4 thoughts on “西部片Top10

  1. 我需要补一下The Hanging Tree和The Wonderful Country,不过大多数情况下,我们都还是在A级西部片那十几个大导演的圈子里打转,没有进入三四十年代的B Western和无声西部片,那里面的水就更深了。

  2. The Hanging Tree没有看过,Allan Dwan的片子只看过一部,正在找Tom Mix和William Hart的早期西部片。法国人比较喜欢与noir有交汇的西部片,比较喜欢revision western。

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.